Fasciatherapy and Reflexology compared to Hypnosis and Music Therapy in Daily Stress Management

  • Bernard Payrau, MD, MT
  • Nadine Quere, MSc, PT, MT Foundig Manager of Ecole bien-être du dos
  • Elisabeth Breton, MSc Founder Manager Ecole de Réflexologie Elisabeth Breton
  • Christine Payrau, MD
Keywords: fasciatherapy, reflexology, hypnosis, music therapy, single session, daily stress, STAI-Y

Abstract

Background: Patients suffering from stress symptoms due to every-day life who are looking for a nonpharmacological response to their relief expectation are many. Furthermore, early reckoning of the day-to-day stress which may lead to clinical diagnosis is the best way of preventing the stress-related diseases. Among the many alternative medicinal options, there is little evidence that fasciatherapy (Fs) and reflexology (Rf) are effective in this field.

Purpose: assess incidence of fasciatherapy Danis Bois Method (DBM) and of reflexology on patients’ stress level in everyday-life, and provide a more informed choice among the numerous mind and body techniques by comparing them with hypnosis (Hp) and music therapy (Mt).

Settings: Specialized Complementary and Alternative Medicine (CAM) centres for outpatients. Participants: 308 individuals (average age =
50.53 SD 14.37, 93 males, 215 females) going to the centres for health care, but free from serious diseases and not heavily medicated respecting the inclusion criteria and providing valid forms.

Research Design: Four armed, non-randomized observational pragmatic trial with pretest–posttest repeated measures, on separate samples of
natural groups.

Intervention: According to the centre participants where they used to be treated, they were exposed to a single semi-standardized session of a technique of their choice: Fs, Rf, Hp, Mt. Volunteers had a controlled non-intervention resting (Rt) session.

Main Outcome Measures: Mean STAI-Y assessing anxiety as reflecting the stress level: MANCOVA and ANCOVA performed with Tukey’s HSD.

Results: MANCOVA indicates a significant reduction of anxiety (p < .01) in each condition, resting included. ANCOVA performance adjusting on stress level in T0 (41.73) and on the mean sumscore of the trait (44.89), Fs (-13.92), Rf (-15.92), and Hp (-15.88) were equally effective on the stress level decrease. Mt (-10.0) and Rt (-6.38) showed the same level of effectiveness.

Conclusions: The results suggest fasciatherapy DBM, hypnosis, and reflexology could be used as non-pharmacological and safe interventions in stress management. Though showing a lesser efficiency, music therapy could be useful in different circumstances.

Author Biographies

Bernard Payrau, MD, MT
MD Cardiologist, MT (Fasciatherapy), Founding Member of Fascia Research Society, Founding Member of Interdisciplanry Working Group for Nonpharmacological Stress Management
Nadine Quere, MSc, PT, MT, Foundig Manager of Ecole bien-être du dos
MSc, PT, MT (Fasciatherapy), Founding Member of Interdisciplanry Working Group for Nonpharmacological Stress Management
Elisabeth Breton, MSc, Founder Manager Ecole de Réflexologie Elisabeth Breton
MSc, Reflexologist, Relaxologist, Founding Member of Interdisciplanry Working Group for Nonpharmacological Stress Management
Christine Payrau, MD
MD, Hypnotherapist, Founding Member of Interdisciplanry Working Group for Nonpharmacological Stress Management
Published
2017-09-12
How to Cite
Payrau, MD, MT, B., Quere, MSc, PT, MT, N., Breton, MSc, E., & Payrau, MD, C. (2017). Fasciatherapy and Reflexology compared to Hypnosis and Music Therapy in Daily Stress Management. International Journal of Therapeutic Massage & Bodywork: Research, Education, & Practice, 10(3), 4-13. https://doi.org/10.3822/ijtmb.v10i3.368
Section
Research